in , ,

Final Fantasy XIII (PS3, Xbox 360): Should it be re-reviewed?

We have an interesting article to show you now, in which an debate has started on whether the recently released Final Fantasy XIII game should be re-reviewed or not.

As most of you will be aware, reviews for the game were fairly good, although there were some exceptions – notably EDGE’s 5/10. The game is a 60 hour+ affair, with the general consensus being that most critics completed their reviews without actually finishing the game.

Over at PSXExtreme, they make the claim that the game changes significantly for the better, past the 20-25 hour mark, when the game reaches the ‘Gran Pulse’ stage.

Have you reached this stage in the game yet? If so, did your overall impressions of the game change after reaching this stage?

This is quite interesting – we’d love to hear your response on this. Should the game be re-reviewed after actually completing the game?

Written by Alan Ng

Alan has been working for Product-Reviews since 2009 and became the Editor-in-chief in 2014. He has a passion for technology, the latest mobile phones and gadgets, and the gaming industry. Alan is a graduate of Canterbury Christ Church University and completed a B.A in Commercial Music in 2008. While expressing a keen interest in all areas that PR cover, you'll usually find Alan in the gaming section, where he'll be keeping enthusiasts up to date on all the latest news and reviews for consoles and PC.

Contact Alan Ng: alan@product-reviews.net

17
Leave a Reply

avatar
16 Comment threads
1 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
14 Comment authors
Kanav15csk8trWyseOwlCheMaxster Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Kanav15
Kanav15

I say this game gets an 8.5 for an slow start to the game bcuz it’s just untill chapter 11 the game gets more fun but just like kingdom hearts this is one of the best RPG’s out there

csk8tr
csk8tr

I'm just starting on Chapter 10 and so far I agree with Shadow and Mark. The graphics and cutscenes are awesome. The "reads like a movie" concept I like. People have said that the game is too linear and while I find that to be true, I kind of like it. It takes confusion out of the equation as far as what to do, especially for those new to the FF series. Things I don't care for: Characters I don't care much for the characters and I do agree that Vanille is annoying. I wish I could control what other… Read more »

WyseOwl
WyseOwl

I'm loving FFXIII so far but that's probably because FF can do no wrong for me. However the entire series is so becoming a triumph of style over substance.

Games developers/authors need telling: "If you want to make films, go make films. If you want to make games, give us good characters, a good plot but most important of all, gameplay!"

Maxster
Maxster

I'm still on Chapter 11. I would say I wasn't really disappointed with the linearity because most latter Final Fantasies have been linear anyway. I guess for a veteran fan like me, there were portions where I would get tired playing it. I quit at Chapter 10. Then played God of War 3 first to break the frustration. Then lo and behold, the moment you reach Gran Pulse stage, the game really opens up and becomes a very satisfying experiencing. I had almost lost faith in the beginning of the game but my hope has been renewed and now I… Read more »

Che
Che

I grew up on the original Final Fantasy on the nintendo where you could choose your characters and go wherever you like. FF13 is a far cry from that. It reminds me of the games where you press left or right to direct the cartoon movie. Dragon Age, Oblivion – these are where RPGs should be headed. Not in the direction of a CGI movie where you press x a few times in between each scene.

youngthanos
youngthanos

I'm about 8hrs in and for the most all I can say is that I don't like the characters to much. In fact that little redhead is down right sickening. She like Yuffie on speed and extasy! Lightning is kind of a b*&*% to and if Snow let's her punch him in the face one more time….. Lastly the main reason I love FF7,8 and 10 so much is because the had good villians so far this faceless enaemy their facing is what turned me off with pt12. Hopely this will change, there are too many other gamse out to… Read more »

Mark
Mark

Plot: 10/10 Graphics: 9.5/10 Characters: 6.5/10 Battle System: 8.5/10 Overall: 9.0/10 It has an amazing plot. There’s no denying that. And apart from auto-attacking, the battle system isn’t all that bad either. The use of paradigms in this game was very good, and gave some dynamics to the battle in place of the loss of the control of all your characters. Still, being in control of one player versus the whole party isn’t as good, as one can find themselves auto-attacking using the same attack or skill over and over again. Furthermore, the auto-attack can get annoying sometimes for certain… Read more »

Ff fan
Ff fan

I'm only at the 15th hour and way before reaching gran pulse but I love the game and is by far one of the best RPGs.

Terry
Terry

i think this game is terrible. rubbish story and characters. really linear(although most ff's are linear, but i think because of recent western rpgs mass effect, fallout 3, oblivion, to mention some are not linear its more noticeable). battle system looks good, but only controlling 1 character in an atb system is boring, and all you have to do after scanning the enemy is auto-whatever. really poor game. tales of vesperia and lost odyssey are my fav jrpgs on 360 so far, cant say for ps3 as i dont have one.

dave
dave

@Shadow

I couldn't agree with you more. stripping those graphics away might change a bunch of minds!

Shadow

Here is what I am finding after reading reviews in comments. The people who this is their first Final Fantasy playing, the game is awesome. The people who liked FFX, the game is again awesome. Those who have played, FF6-12, the review are mixed and head towards the negative generally. Those who have played FF6-12 and have played other RPGs like Breath Of Fire Series, Dragon Quest series and so forth, the game gets negative reviews. The last one is where my opinion comes in because I've played down to FF2 to 12 with a bunch of other RPG titles,… Read more »

anatanooreo
anatanooreo

what would people have said if it wasn't final fantasy XIII?

sol
sol

definately the best rpg i have come across, im not at gran pulse yet but the game is an absolute beast its immense storyline is gripping and the gameplay is phenomenal

Bob
Bob

It became a painful chore at that point. Needless repetition.

Hitting bad guys 25000 times is not fun, character start to feel weaker as the game progresses.

Lee
Lee

Call me crazy, but I would expect reviewers to complete games before publishing their thoughts! Re-reviewing shouldn't be required, just do it right the first time!

dave
dave

If you want a game reviewed in your favor, you should make it good from hour 1, not 21. It's like being born blind, and gaining sight and winning the lottery at age 30. It's a momentous paradox! It's a circumstance few have ever encountered and cannot relate to. Is this circumstance great? It is stale at first, but then is terrific. You're consumed with decaying hope, and then you are alleviated. The pattern this game takes is a new algorithm of progression. Games have been made to: Give hope to the gamer, then supply. Good game! Give hope to… Read more »

Microsoft and Datal: If the pad looks the same, we’ll sue you

iPhone Apps: New app for 2010 – Bull Stampede 1.0