Kinect Xbox 360 Review: Room Size Issues and Hand-Gesture Lag?

By Alan Ng - Nov 4, 2010

Today is officially Xbox 360 Kinect today and with it, the collection of ‘official’ reviews are now starting to pour out, as Microsoft has finally given the green light for the embargo to be lifted.

We’re going to provide you with a review round-up later on, but this detailed review by Engadget has caught our attention, since the tech site has only scored it a 6/10 – citing a few key issues which have been well documented prior to release.

Firstly, their biggest gripe with Kinect is the fact about Microsoft’s recommendation requirement to play Kinect from at least six feet away from your TV set. They mention how every Kinect game you play reminds you about the size recommendations, but Engadget point out that this isn’t an easy task to complete, especially in smaller-sized living rooms.

One of their other criticisms of the hardware, is the fact that using hand gestures to input commands into Kinect seem to take longer than they should do – i.e a few seconds. Engadget even go as far to say that using the Kinect menu UI is ‘a painful reminder that pushing a button is so much quicker and more convenient.’

They do say that the technology in general is great, and that the voice commands and Kinect Video features work great, but conclude their review by saying that Kinect ‘has a lot of growing up to do’.

What are your thoughts on this? Has it put you off slightly from making a purchase? Read the full review over at Engadget.

Follow us on Facebook, Twitter or Google Plus.

Also See: Could Microsoft’s Folding Tablet be the gadget of 2018?

  • hmmmm

    hows this for room size? sure its a big room behind him but he sure is closer than 6 feet

    • curious

      was the avatar suppose to mirror the reporter in the last game?

  • Randall

    Reports now coming in from people getting their hands on this thing and what I'm hearing so far is backing up every issue those of us being rational on the subject of Kinect have had. It don't quite work as advertised.

    Fanboys can cry bias and foul all they want, but keep watching forums and reviews the next week or so and the truth will be clear. Microsoft weren't going to be able to keep the smoke and mirrors up forever.

  • Jake

    They are biased! They are a APPLE company. They are paid to hate microsoft..simple!