Diablo 3 Petition: What’s your view?

I personally like the art as its very reminiscent of Diablo 1 and Diablo 2 which I’ve enjoyed tremendously. In fact I will as far as saying two of my favourite all-times games.

I would be very disappointed if the Blizzard changed the art to match WoW which I personally find *boring*.

Diablo 3 IMO has retained the look and feel of its predecessors which is really about solo game-play.

I think the originality of the first Diablo was the contrast between gloomy dungeon atmosphere and a peaceful and sad city where the hero was welcomed by happy fellows just after he had crushed legions of minions. This was also due to the small battle area: you only had to go up and down in a dungeon, then come back to the outside, in the city of Tristram, where you couldn’t now exactly if this city was recomforting or worrisome.

In diablo 2, they decided to turn the hero into a world explorer, crushing thousands of demons in every part of Sanctuary, always running, running, running…The environment in cities and combat areas was almost the same. You could find monsters at the gates of the cities. Contrary to its predecessor, diablo 1, you were exploring hell or dungeons but yet it was encouraging, even in hell. And you were killing cartoon monsters.

So this new formula, dungeon/large areas outside, has already brought many changes in diablo 2. If they go on like this, creating even larger battle areas, aesthetic demons, encouraging atmospheres, the game will turn into something else… Between hellish environments and beautiful landscapes… Thats a radical change since diablo 1, where you could feel hell and despair in every aspect of the game.

What they’ve shown looks pretty I guess. It also looks like world of warcraft. While the dated visuals of WoW are ok for a MMO game as old as it is they don’t really hold up for a modern isometric scroller game.

I’d expect a lot more detail and mood than what i’ve seen. Heck even Titan Quest was more detailed than the D3 art i’ve seen so far, and that game is a few years old.

Hopefully Blizzard isn’t planning on downgrading the quality of their art to the lowest common denominator. Or hasn’t brainwashed all their artists into thinking that less is more when it comes to texture design.

Yes, style is important, but can’t you have style and detail? Why does style have to be plain and smooth? Diablo is certainly not a “plain and smooth” game. So the graphics shouldn’t be.

I think the petitioners have a point. It would be a sad day if Blizzard decided to just let Diablo fall into WoWs art shadow instead of building that IP up into something original looking.

I have to agree with Bobby & Andrew, in their demo of Diablo3, I’m not quite excited as I am supposed to be. “Wall of skeleton” – What’s up with that! “Destructive Environments!” – kinda useless for me. “Picturesque Atmosphere!” Hhhhhhhhmmm – Naah! Give me a dark, kinda like a lonely atmosphere in the game!

I wished D3 is like a prequel and Deckard Cain is a playable character! LOL. Coz how could there be diablo3 when his soul stone was destroyed already!! Cloned Diablo?!

I have to admit, the directions that they have with the characters is truly amazing the barbarian is now so cool though i never played as a barbarain before. The witch doctor is okay. But where is my druid and sorcerer?!

I didn’t think anything against the new diablo 3 look but after seeing a few screenshots where people did a side by side comparison, the edited screens did look like what i would want it to be, much grittier looking, like diablo 2 but still with the improved gfx/physics engine.

omma kudikala enna da eppadi sunny madhiri game engine iruku evan ipadi kandu puduchano avn vayilaya vanakaran sunnya vaika

seriously, i believe that the gameplay is what will keep diablo 3 strong. id be playing diablo 2 right know, but the only thing holding me back are the graphics and the crap resolution support. As long as diablo 3 retains the gameplay of its predecessors, and new graphics which do look good! I will be pre-ordering it the minute it is avaliable.

Diablo 3 is going to reinvent the saga. Why do I say this? It’s simple. Diablos concept is a/the hero(s) save the day, light winning over darkness. It has been X years since darkness cast a shade, and there is bound to be some beauty in the way of the ‘graphics’. I mean, come on people, it makes sense. Diablo 3 brings two aspects to the table that the old diablos didn’t have. the first is new designers. If you want dark, and dreary, stop whining and go play HELLGATE: London, made by the ORIGINAL diablo creators. Diablo 3 has new people, extremely similar gameplay, and some kick ass graphics compared to the prequels.

@antondias: How could there be a sequel eh? go watch the teaser movies and the interview with the project leader. there are two evils they DIDN’T kill.

Seriously, have these ppl even watched the gameplay trailer????? Diablo 3 is more diablo than diablo 2 was. If they’re complaining about 3D graphics engine and some internet connectivity options, then they need a Pentium 1 233 so they can play Diablo 1 and 2.
I’ve heard so much FUD about diablo 3 from ppl who know nothing about it and havent watched any of the vids. Just look at what is on their site or read some serious reviews, maybe from ppl in the industry.
http://bushweed.blogspot.com/2008/07/diablo-iii-and-pillars-of-stupidity.html

D3 looks damn awesome, there’s no denying it. But, having played and love the first two Diablo games, I honestly have to say that I agree with the petitioners. When I first watched the video, although it looked impressive, there was something lacking. That something was the haunting, dark, oppressive ‘evil’ feel that the predecessor evoked.

For me, the point at which I decided that I fully agreed with the petitioners was when I compared the game screenshots, to the modified images, which had the ominous and gritty feel I have come to associate with Diablo. I signed the petition, and don’t regret it, despite the many flames I have recieved for it all over the internet.

(continued from previous)

…and don’t regret it despite the many insults and flames it has garnered me. All over the internet, people have overreacted to this, and are flinging fairly severe and offensive insults to those who dared to offer Blizzard some constructive criticism.

As of now, there are about 48 thousands petitioners, including myself!?

Just try to see the comparison that they’ve make. I will be very happy if the look of D3 are the one’s the petitioner’s recommend.

Try to see for yourself
http://www.petitiononline.com/d3art/

Personally I think the complaints are not entirely justified. Yes, I do think that D-3 borrows from the Warcraft styles, especially in the character department and yes I agree that Warcraft ISN’T Diablo…However…Blizzard should be given the benifit of the doubt when it comes to its own games! These guys know their stuff and have made some damn good games in the past. I think people are crying over nothing and in the end D-3 will turn out just fine. I actually signed the petition, but mostly due to the message it sends Blizzard, that we want a SERIOUS game and not a cartoony one. Im sure they’ve heard it loud and clear…nuff said.

Spot on Bobby…

they’ve alredy fucked up starcraft which looks exactly like warcraft now!
and now there “brightening” up diablo? wtf thats stupid there destroying the image of the classics

just because they make a lot of money from W.O.W doesn’t mean they have ot make everything a w.o.w clone in order to make a popular game

I dont get this at all, Ya, Diablo was, dark, and gloomy , and all emo for you fanboys, but I personally hated the darkness of the game. You coulden’t see whats going on everywhere, and end up chaseing some devil kin around for half an hour,that part sucked.

Also Ive found you can sign that “petition” multiple times… so I dont belive the number is really that high. Nerds aren’t above spending a few hours a day clicking on website.

Hey guys just so you know, I mean I know Diablo one and two are like two of the best games ever, but that does not mean you HAVE to but the Third! So quite your bitchen, when you know your gonna pony up the dough anyway!

Youd buy Diablo 3, if it was a remake of Diablo !

P.S. To the people who complain about a WoW clone: This is an entertainment industry,… There trying to make money. There not trying to get put into a museum. WoW style looks made alot of money, So naturally its gonna take some overtones from that.

Um… I have checked it out and I am a huge fan of the series and I had to go change my pants after viewing the game play demo. It was total geekgasm time.

I don’t get what people are complaining about. This not the designers of the original game or of Diablo 2. Those guys put out Hellgate London.

yes, and hellgate london sucked. so clearly there is something about blizzard which makes their game fun and addictive.

I like the new look. I played D1 and D2, and frankly the only negative was the “too dark” look to it. I didn’t spend thousands on a high end gaming computer to NOT be able to see a game. Think about it…

Blizzard Rocks! Keep up the good work dudes!!

your #1 fan

Michel Mate

I would have thought they would have gone with porportional sized characters and environments by now, honestly. example: at the character selection of D2.
Imagine Soul Reaver & Defiance engine meets Diablo. Although, the birds eye view has always been the diablo trademark, the art style of Diablo3 made me think of Gauntlet meets Super Mario Bros. I think the first combo would have been far superior =P Anyway, the issue that people are seeing is the amount of saturation of color being used and fake catoonish lighting ex. “blue means dark and scary” =O which takes away from the semi-realistic feel that would have been expected in the 3rd installment of Diablo. BUT HEY! at least gamers will be blessed & cursed with another addicting game in the first place…..

my guild and I seriously can’t wait for Diablo III to go beta… Blizzard’s been saying “It’s ready, when it’s ready” stating that they are fixing out the bugs for millions to enjoy.